What to do Next: Gaudreau Update

This year has been a disaster. Unfortunately, this is nothing new. We have all seen this movie before. You would think the Flames would know this script and maybe change it up a bit. It is like they don't believe they need to change. When the teams fail over and over to meet expectations, usually the coach gets the axe. This year was no exception. Mr. Ward got the axe, and in came Mr. Daryl Sutter. With Sutter, we got to see heads roll. Players were motivated to play winning hockey, and the players did perform... for about four games. Then the old habits began to rear their ugly heads, and sure enough, the team fell into that dark hole otherwise known as oblivion. If you like Star Trek: there seems to be a rip in the space-time continuum. 

The first problem the Flames have had is automatically firing coaches and not looking at the root of the problem. I am not saying keeping Ward would have been the solution; I am saying you have the right players for the coach. If you bring in a disciplinarian, you need the players who will respond to him. Or, as my hero of Stampede wrestling days, Ed Whalen, says, "What we have here is a malfunction at the junction." A coach's job to put his players in the best position for success. For Sutter to achieve his goals, he must have Sutter players.  

When a team fails to reach its ultimate goal, it is easy to blame the players. And that is what management does when hiring a new coach does not produce results. Like it or not, the first place they look is the core of the roster. To keep with the Star Trek theme, it is only logical.   

Our Captain is at the age where he needs more help in the leadership role. I see too many passengers and not enough leaders on this team. What they need is a young Lucic with some skill who can learn from Milan. Sutter knows this team needs some players who know how to win. More Gios and Milans. The only way there going to get those kinds of players is trading talent back. 

Will this be the year Gaudreau is moved? Will the Flyers find a way? Will the Islanders or Rangers make a run at Gaudreau? Or do the Flames try to keep Johnny and consider dealing Monahan? The most likely choice is Gaudreau because the return is higher. Although, one can argue more teams are looking for a Centre.  I could see the Rangers and Canadiens looking at Monahan. Only time will tell. The Flames will be busy around the draft. Rumour is, they would like to clear up some salary in the off-season. 

Randy

Go, Johnny, Go—I Mean—Stay, Johnny, Stay!

The hottest topic among Flames fans at the moment is what the Flames will do with Johnny Gaudreau (who will be known as Johnny Hockey from now on.) It is almost like an election. Wait—this is not democracy. The Flames don't care what the fans want. Sometimes I think we would be better off if they did. But I digress. Back to the real focus of this blog.  

The Flames have been a colossal disappointment all season. We know that this core can't do what it takes to get us to the promised land. 

It is time for a change. This franchise has gone stagnant. Whether or not it is fair, Johnny Gaudreau is always under scrutiny. 

The Cons of Trading Johnny Gaudreau

Johnny is a very talented hockey player, and they don't grow on trees. Losing an arguably top-ten player can be catastrophic. Who will pick up the slack in the offence?

The second con is, how is this going to affect Monahan? Sometimes you have to worry about a player's ego and baby him a little. Monahan's season may even get worse without Gaudreau. Who is going to feed him the puck? Monahan stats will take it a hit. It will take him a while to get used to a new linemate. You have to consider moving Monahan, which could be a huge undertaking. 

The third con is that you are not going to get an equal trade. If a team gives you an equal left-winger, they will consider that a lateral move, meaning the trade will not improve their team. You know that the team will not be better after this trade.

The Pros of Trading Gaudreau

Johnny is the star of the team. He is the greatest bang for your buck. There is no doubt Johnny will get you the most significant return in a deal. You will get three assets back in a trade. The Flames need help in the prospect pool and help in the defensive core. They will get that and more in a trade involving Johnny. 

This team is in dire need of a shakeup. There is no greater shakeup than trading the star of the team. The Flames lack an identity; it's time to remedy that. They are only as good as their best star, and he is not getting it done. It might not be fair, but when things go wrong, the star gets the blame. It is a fact of life, just like death and taxes. 

Last word

One thing is for sure—the Flames need a change. Tinkering is just not going to cut it. I would love to see a total rebuild. I know that will never happen, so that I will settle for a retool. 

Randy